2026

• Andrew Cole - Randolph-Macon College
• Anthony Ferrie - Methodist University
• Theo Manna - Bard College
• Matthew Swanson - James Madison University

2025

• Hamilton Adams - Johns Hopkins University
• Matthew Gentry - Richard Bland College
• Daniel Guntherberg - Paul D. Camp Community College

2024

• Ayden Evans - Hampden-Sydney College
• Luke Harlow - Ohio State University
• Davis Neighbor - Hampden-Sydney College
• Will Wyles - Hampden-Sydney College

2023

• Trey Christman - William and Mary
• Wilson Estep - Regent University
• Wyatt Helsel - Randolph Macon College
• Ryan Terrell - Christopher Newport University

2022

• Donnie Evans - Hampden-Sydney College
• Jacob Miller-Bopp - Hampden-Sydney College

2021

• Tyler Gorbett - University of Virginia's College at Wise
• Lincoln Lubsen - Randolph-Macon College

2020

• Tanner Schobel - Virginia Tech

2019

• Christian Carter - California University of Pennsylvania
• Zach Stanko - Longwood University
• Ethan Weaver - Christopher Newport University

2018

• Tredell Blow - Bryant & Stratton College
• Jason Covaney - Hampden-Sydney College